{
  "_doc": "One result, read from the codebase’s own files at the commit named here. Every value is that file’s own, copied verbatim; nothing here is written by hand. A value replaced by {withheld: true, sha256_of_value, bytes} is committed by its sha256 instead of published, for the reason it states, and is never edited. Each whole source file is committed by sha256 below, and its bytes are published only where its visibility says so. The codebase is named by the public subject its files are published under.",
  "lane": "packaging-extraction",
  "repository": "packaging-extraction",
  "commit": "b8d9325aea6d8ef103cb3d1dd1c4ba77bd80ee2f",
  "portfolio_id": "packaging-extraction:priced-scaling-law",
  "id": "priced-scaling-law",
  "attestation_row": {
    "attested_at": "2026-09-19",
    "attestor": "07-genesis",
    "repository": "genesis",
    "source_doc": "CROWN_JEWELS_RESOLVED.md",
    "source_doc_sha256": "781bf515d77ef14469d543ce87b2a15d0420237f5a9bc9b1a7b4899d0f935cb7",
    "state": "attested",
    "top_n": 31,
    "note_sha256": "1218191deb85b45fe5d2ef07e47c7d4e6c09061b6b8386e86759a6105204cd17",
    "ids_in_row": 31,
    "file": "dataroom/TOP_N_ATTESTATION.jsonl",
    "line": 1
  },
  "claim_source": {
    "receipt": "packaging-extraction/top40.json",
    "sha256": "1dca1ae6d762bd584ae11aa353701b702e3378cf912d8d64ec065e74f589319e",
    "field": "entries[22].claim",
    "file": "top40.json"
  },
  "top40_entry": {
    "id": "priced-scaling-law",
    "rank": 23,
    "title": "The priced neural scaling law",
    "claim": "Operator error scales as N^-0.532 over 2.68 decades with log-log R²=0.995, and the parameter exponent 0.255 is smaller than the data exponent — so the binding constraint is owned data, not model size.",
    "scope": "Three gated qualifiers travel with it and none is optional: BNSL is PREFERRED over a single power law, the fit FAILS forward-validation, and the practical rule is unsupported beyond about N=50,000.",
    "limits": "THE GATE'S OWN PASS STRING PRINTS 'halve error -> 3.7x data' UNQUALIFIED, and that is a LIVE PROSE DEFECT visible verbatim in the output above. Gate 125 shows BNSL preferred (ΔAIC 5.41 / ΔBIC 4.81 — evidence of curvature, though the fitted break sits ~3.85 decades beyond the data and is NOT identified). Gate 126 shows the fit predicts N=51,200 well and misses N=96,000. It supersedes β = 0.59 over 1.72 decades, which sat inside its own bootstrap CI. A leakage-filtered re-fit moves β by only +0.031/−0.009, so the OPERATOR scaling law is not a duplication artifact — unlike the Z₀ corpus, which is.",
    "artifact_path": "benchmarks/ws1inf/scaling_law_100k_2026_06_30.json",
    "witness_command": "PYTHONPATH=. python3 scripts/audit/verify_scaling_law_gate.py",
    "witness_result": "exit=0 · EXIT0_NO_TOUCH · fault-injection: corrupt-beta + increasing-error witnesses both correctly REJECTED.",
    "witness_class": "ASSERTING",
    "witness_class_basis": "measured",
    "third_party_axis": "-",
    "facts": {
      "ran_with_receipt": true,
      "third_party_graded": false,
      "negative_control_stated": true,
      "ip_class_known": false,
      "reproduce_command": true,
      "regenerates_not_verifies": false
    },
    "facts_count": 3,
    "repro_command": "PYTHONPATH=. python3 scripts/audit/verify_scaling_law_gate.py",
    "reproduce_command": "PYTHONPATH=. python3 scripts/audit/verify_scaling_law_gate.py",
    "repro_packet": null,
    "ip_class": "UNKNOWN",
    "evidence_tier": "SIMULATED",
    "run_status": "RAN",
    "output_excerpt": "PASS: error ~ N^-0.532 (log-log R2=0.995); halve error -> 3.7x data. Re-derived from 10 sweep points, consistent with stored fit. | params^-0.255 (R2=0.840, 5 pts; data-bound: alpha<=beta)\n  fault-injection: corrupt-beta + increasing-error witnesses both correctly REJECTED.",
    "attestation_rank": 28,
    "negative_control": "corrupt-β and increasing-error witnesses both REJECTED"
  },
  "witness_quality_entry": {
    "id": "priced-scaling-law",
    "portfolio_id": "genesis:priced-scaling-law",
    "class": "ASSERTING",
    "measured_class": "ASSERTING",
    "basis": "measured",
    "why": {
      "withheld": true,
      "why": "uses a word the published record keeps for its own process (S3.1-DIALECT)",
      "sha256_of_value": "b2f9db01a6b896e56b41b363258f95c2541de0ec16dd96a7fa4266ae80f8f381",
      "bytes": 318
    },
    "witness_command": "PYTHONPATH=. python3 scripts/audit/verify_scaling_law_gate.py",
    "exit_clean": 0,
    "exit_mutated": 1,
    "asserts": "FAIL: re-derived beta=0.5320 != stored 0.931 (witness fit inconsistent)"
  },
  "packet": null,
  "measured": {
    "measured": true,
    "basis": "exit_mutated = 1 (basis == measured)",
    "exit": 1,
    "defect_rejected": true
  },
  "register": {
    "truth_state": "attested",
    "truth_line": 202,
    "measured_per_register": true,
    "witness_class_per_register": "ASSERTING",
    "ip_class_public": "not_public",
    "ip_class_sha256": "c2ab54a718ff5484fea4f59ecc2a446deef5412ea225434433529a34a9764660",
    "ip_class_source": "docs/audit/CHIPLETOS_CANON_FACTS_2026_09_17.json:34 @ e47033d4758e",
    "receipt": "register/CROWN_JEWELS_TRUTH.md",
    "receipt_sha256": "bde06cf0d3e99644522d18e79b6bd5d84ed4f5c86e315a48fef207e9e49c5022",
    "ip_class_receipt": "register/ip_class.jsonl",
    "ip_class_receipt_sha256": "b1e8f97aa6779e0fefed2f7a7726e1a03563b536b497392401b49bb8ef84d4ca"
  },
  "withheld_fields": [
    {
      "field": "witness_quality.why",
      "codes": [
        "PROCESS_NARRATION"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "sources": {
    "attestation": {
      "receipt": "packaging-extraction/dataroom/TOP_N_ATTESTATION.jsonl",
      "source": "dataroom/TOP_N_ATTESTATION.jsonl",
      "commit": "b8d9325aea6d8ef103cb3d1dd1c4ba77bd80ee2f",
      "sha256": "73bf88d1ecd6c3299599f1929a6fda2e3b20dbe725d908375a1aec5038f199e8",
      "bytes": 3855,
      "visibility": "sealed"
    },
    "top40": {
      "receipt": "packaging-extraction/top40.json",
      "source": "top40.json",
      "commit": "b8d9325aea6d8ef103cb3d1dd1c4ba77bd80ee2f",
      "sha256": "1dca1ae6d762bd584ae11aa353701b702e3378cf912d8d64ec065e74f589319e",
      "bytes": 245175,
      "visibility": "sealed"
    },
    "witness_quality": {
      "receipt": "packaging-extraction/dataroom/witness_quality.json",
      "source": "dataroom/witness_quality.json",
      "commit": "b8d9325aea6d8ef103cb3d1dd1c4ba77bd80ee2f",
      "sha256": "a5b45f767596df7e20404884fd30f0975b1931cf08bb7f3b4e4bfc4b83073c51",
      "bytes": 161552,
      "visibility": "sealed"
    },
    "repro_index": {
      "receipt": "packaging-extraction/repro/INDEX.json",
      "source": "repro/INDEX.json",
      "commit": "b8d9325aea6d8ef103cb3d1dd1c4ba77bd80ee2f",
      "sha256": "3e1cdc5f09bf5c34a582d32529e944a4fe565211faccceb3dc5a7a1724f68635",
      "bytes": 28509,
      "visibility": "sealed"
    }
  }
}